Home/Where to stay/Pickering/4-star hotels
4-star hotels in Pickering
Four 4-star places to stay around Pickering, from town-centre inns to farm cottages and lodges on the edge of the North York Moors. For couples, families and anyone exploring the moors by car or steam railway.
Staying in Pickering
Pickering is a working market town that also happens to be the southern terminus of the North Yorkshire Moors Railway, so the streets fill with visitors from mid-morning and empty again by late afternoon. St Peter and St Paul's church above Market Place holds 15th-century wall paintings that were whitewashed at the Reformation and uncovered in 1852 — free to see and rarely busy. Pickering Castle and the Beck Isle Museum are both in town, and Malton is 20 minutes away, Scarborough 45.
The 4-star stays here sit in and around the town rather than in one quarter. The White Swan Inn and The Old Manse Pickering are in Pickering itself, on Market Place and Middleton Road respectively. Others are in outlying villages — Sinnington, Levisham, Allerston, Cropton — and on farms such as Craven Garth, Hartoft and Middleton. That range suits couples wanting a pub with rooms, families needing space, and anyone with a car who would rather wake up in the moors than on the square.
The shortlist
Ranked by hotel class, then guest rating and number of reviews.
The Horseshoe Inn
Main Street Levisham, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers
- Free car parking
- Kitchen
- Free Wifi
Why stay hereOn Main Street in Levisham, The Horseshoe Inn is a 4-star village base with free car parking and a garden for slow afternoons; golf and horse back riding are close at hand. Guests score it 4.8 from 788 reviews, so it suits couples and walkers who want a settled, well-run place to return to after a day in the North York Moors.
See The Horseshoe InnLow Costa Mill
Costa Lane, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Families · Drivers
- Indoor pool
- Free car parking
- Pets allowed
Why stay hereLow Costa Mill suits families and pet owners: it has an indoor pool, a playground and self-catering kitchens, plus free car parking and a garden. Fishing and horse back riding are within reach of this 4-star Pickering address, and its 4.8 rating from 101 reviews reflects how consistently it delivers for longer stays.
See Low Costa MillCraven Garth Cottages
Craven Garth Farm, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Families · Drivers
- Free car parking
- Pets allowed
- Family rooms
Why stay hereCraven Garth Cottages is a working-farm setting on Craven Garth Farm, with kitchenettes and fireplaces in the cottages, a garden and free car parking. Pets are allowed, fishing and golf are nearby, and the 4.8 rating from 100 reviews makes it a good fit for families or groups who want countryside self-catering rather than a hotel room.
See Craven Garth CottagesThe Fox and Hounds Country Inn
Main Street Sinnington, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers · Breakfast
- Free car parking
- Breakfast in room
- Wheelchair accessible
Why stay hereThe Fox and Hounds Country Inn combines a restaurant and bar with a garden and terrace on Main Street in Sinnington, and it is wheelchair accessible. Golf and horse back riding are close by, and room service is available; its 4.6 rating from 443 reviews suits guests who want a country inn with proper dining on site.
See The Fox and Hounds Country InnThe Cayley Arms
Allerston Pickering Yo18 7Pj, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers
- Free car parking
- Free Wifi
Why stay hereGolf, fishing and horse back riding are all within reach. Rated 4.6 from 438 reviews, it works well for guests who want a sociable 4-star inn with meals handled on site.
See The Cayley ArmsThe White Swan Inn
Market Place, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Families · Drivers
- Free car parking
- Breakfast
- Family rooms
Why stay hereOn Market Place in Pickering, The White Swan Inn gives you breakfast, a restaurant and bar, room service and a terrace, with family rooms and babysitting service available. Its 4.4 rating comes from 668 reviews, and the central address suits guests who want to step out to shops and eateries rather than drive everywhere.
See The White Swan InnBramwood Cottages
Bramwood Cottages Kirkham Lane, Pickering, United Kingdom
- Wifi
Why stay hereBramwood Cottages on Kirkham Lane is a small 4-star option with Wifi and a 4.6 rating, though only 12 reviews so far. It suits guests who prefer a quiet, self-contained cottage base near Pickering and do not need bars, restaurants or leisure facilities on the doorstep.
See Bramwood CottagesThe Barn at Rigg End
Hartoft Farm, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers
- Free car parking
- Kitchen
- Free Wifi
Why stay hereThe Barn at Rigg End is a 4-star barn conversion at Hartoft Farm with a fireplace, a kitchen and a balcony or terrace, plus free car parking and a garden. Rated a perfect 5.0 from 7 reviews, it is best for couples or small families seeking a peaceful self-catering retreat with room to spread out.
See The Barn at Rigg End25 West End
25 West End Goathland Goathland United Kingdom, Kirkbymoorside, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers
- Free car parking
- Kitchen
- Free Wifi
Why stay here25 West End is a compact 4-star cottage in Goathland with a kitchen, free car parking and free Wifi, rated 4.8 from 6 reviews. It suits independent travellers who want a simple self-catering base for exploring the moors and villages, with towels and ironing facilities provided.
See 25 West EndThe Barn at Noelles Cottages
The Barn Noelle's Cottages Middleton Hall Middleton, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers
- Free car parking
- Kitchen
- Free Wifi
Why stay hereThe Barn at Noelles Cottages, at Middleton Hall, offers a fireplace, kitchen, dishwasher and patio along with free car parking and a garden. Cots and high chairs are provided, so families are well catered for. Its 4.4 rating from 5 reviews reflects a handful of satisfied self-catering stays near Pickering.
See The Barn at Noelles CottagesHigh Farm Bed & Breakfast
High Farm Cropton Pickering Yo18 8Hl Uk, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers · Breakfast
- Free car parking
- Breakfast
Why stay hereHigh Farm Bed & Breakfast in Cropton keeps things simple: breakfast, free car parking, a garden and free internet access in the lounge, in a non-smoking house. This 4-star farm stay suits guests who want a quiet rural B&B base for the moors without the extras of a larger inn.
See High Farm Bed & BreakfastThe Old Manse Pickering
19 Middleton Road, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers · Travelling with pets
- Free car parking
- Lounge
- Pets allowed
Why stay hereThe Old Manse Pickering on Middleton Road adds a restaurant and bar, terrace, garden and bike rental to its 4-star rooms, with air conditioning and free car parking. Pets are allowed and special diets can be catered for, making it a practical choice for cyclists, pet owners and guests wanting meals on site.
See The Old Manse PickeringRocklands Lodges
Cawthone Lane, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Families · Drivers
- Free car parking
- Pets allowed
- Family rooms
Why stay hereRocklands Lodges off Cawthorne Lane offers lodges with balconies, kitchens and a jacuzzi, plus free car parking, a garden and terraces. Pets are allowed and family rooms are available, with express check-in. It suits guests who want self-catering space with a bit of comfort and easy access to Pickering.
See Rocklands LodgesRawcliffe House Farm
Stape Rd Pickering England Yo18 8Ja, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Drivers · Step-free access
- Free car parking
- Wheelchair accessible
- Free Wifi
Why stay hereRawcliffe House Farm on Stape Road provides bicycle hire, a garden, picnic area and playground, with horse back riding nearby and a shuttle service. Free car parking and free Wifi are included. This 4-star farm stay suits active guests and families who want to cycle or walk from the door.
See Rawcliffe House FarmBarker Stakes Farm
Lendales Lane, Pickering, United Kingdom
Best for: Families · Drivers
- Free car parking
- Pets allowed
- Family rooms
Why stay hereBarker Stakes Farm on Lendales Lane has self-catering kitchens, a jacuzzi, a playground and table tennis, plus a garden and free car parking. Fishing and golf are nearby, and pets are welcome. It is a strong 4-star pick for families or groups who want outdoor space and things to do on site.
See Barker Stakes Farm
The shortlist side by side
| Hotel | Class | Guest rating | Reviews | Parking | Breakfast | Pets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Horseshoe Inn | ★★★★ | 4.8 | 788 | Yes | – | – |
| Low Costa Mill | ★★★★ | 4.8 | 101 | Yes | – | Yes |
| Craven Garth Cottages | ★★★★ | 4.8 | 100 | Yes | – | Yes |
| The Fox and Hounds Country Inn | ★★★★ | 4.6 | 443 | Yes | Yes | – |
| The Cayley Arms | ★★★★ | 4.6 | 438 | Yes | – | – |
| The White Swan Inn | ★★★★ | 4.4 | 668 | Yes | Yes | – |
| Bramwood Cottages | ★★★★ | 4.6 | 12 | – | – | – |
| The Barn at Rigg End | ★★★★ | 5.0 | 7 | Yes | – | – |
| 25 West End | ★★★★ | 4.8 | 6 | Yes | – | – |
| The Barn at Noelles Cottages | ★★★★ | 4.4 | 5 | Yes | – | – |
| High Farm Bed & Breakfast | ★★★★ | – | – | Yes | Yes | – |
| The Old Manse Pickering | ★★★★ | – | – | Yes | – | Yes |
| Rocklands Lodges | ★★★★ | – | – | Yes | – | Yes |
| Rawcliffe House Farm | ★★★★ | – | – | Yes | – | – |
| Barker Stakes Farm | ★★★★ | – | – | Yes | – | Yes |
From each hotel's own listing on this site; a dash means it is not listed.
How to choose
For families
Low Costa Mill has an indoor pool, a playground, family rooms and high chairs. Barker Stakes Farm adds table tennis, a playground and family rooms. Craven Garth Cottages and The Cayley Arms both have family-sized and self-catering facilities, and all four have free car parking.
Low Costa Mill · Barker Stakes Farm · Craven Garth Cottages · The Cayley Arms
For couples
The White Swan Inn is on Market Place with a restaurant and terrace; The Fox and Hounds Country Inn has a restaurant, bar and terrace in Sinnington. The Old Manse Pickering offers a garden and lounge, and The Barn at Rigg End is a quiet farm retreat with a fireplace and balcony.
The White Swan Inn · The Fox and Hounds Country Inn · The Old Manse Pickering · The Barn at Rigg End
Top guest ratings
The Barn at Rigg End scores 5.0 from 7 reviews. The Horseshoe Inn and Low Costa Mill each score 4.8 from 788 and 101 reviews respectively, and Craven Garth Cottages also scores 4.8 from 100 reviews — the highest-rated cluster among these Pickering properties.
The Barn at Rigg End · The Horseshoe Inn · Low Costa Mill · Craven Garth Cottages
Pets and parking
Craven Garth Cottages, Rocklands Lodges, Barker Stakes Farm, The Old Manse Pickering and Low Costa Mill all allow pets. Every one of them also has free car parking, which matters if you are driving out to the moors or the coast.
Craven Garth Cottages · Rocklands Lodges · Barker Stakes Farm · The Old Manse Pickering · Low Costa Mill
Where to stay in Pickering
Sinnington
The Fox and Hounds Country Inn is on Main Street in Sinnington, one of the villages east of Pickering on the edge of the moors. A country inn setting with a restaurant, bar and terrace, and free car parking for exploring the surrounding lanes.
Our picks here: The Fox and Hounds Country Inn
Levisham
The Horseshoe Inn stands on Main Street in Levisham, a moorland village served by its own station on the North Yorkshire Moors Railway. Woodland and moor walks are on the doorstep, and the inn has a garden, picnic area and free car parking.
Our picks here: The Horseshoe Inn
Allerston
The Cayley Arms is in Allerston, west of Pickering on the A170 towards the moors. It has a restaurant, bar, garden and free car parking, making it a straightforward stop for drivers heading between Pickering and the moorland villages.
Our picks here: The Cayley Arms
Plan your stay
Getting there and around
Pickering is the southern terminus of the North Yorkshire Moors Railway, which runs whatever the weather with warm carriages. Malton is 20 minutes away and Scarborough 45 minutes. Parking on Market Place fills first because the square is busy from around 10am to 4pm through July and August. The town suits arriving early: outside the peak hours and the event weekends, an early start puts you ahead of almost everyone.
When to go
July and August are the busiest months, with Market Place and the station area packed from around 10am to 4pm and parking on the square filling first. The real pressure points are North Yorkshire Moors Railway gala weekends, the traction engine rally in August and the 1940s wartime weekend in October, when the town is effectively full. Outside those, an early start puts you ahead of almost everyone. Note that Pickering has limited wet-weather capacity for a full day, so plan indoor time at the Beck Isle Museum or the church.
Things to do near Pickering
- Family Autumn Walks Near Pickering: Where to Base Yourself
- Five-Star Stays on the North Yorkshire Moors Railway: Luxury Bases in Pickering, Grosmont and Goathland
- One day in the North York Moors: Pickering to Whitby, hour by hour
- Pickering with Kids: A Practical Guide for Families
- Where to Sleep on the North Yorkshire Moors Railway: Pickering, Grosmont and Goathland Compared
- Where to stay in Pickering: a base for the Moors railway and Dalby
Questions, answered
Which of these hotels is closest to Pickering town centre?
The White Swan Inn is on Market Place and The Old Manse Pickering is on Middleton Road, both in Pickering itself. The others sit in surrounding villages — Sinnington, Levisham, Allerston, Cropton, Middleton and Hartoft — and are best reached by car.
Do any of these hotels have a pool?
Low Costa Mill has both an indoor pool and a swimming pool. No other property in this shortlist lists a pool among its facilities.
Which hotels allow pets?
Low Costa Mill, Craven Garth Cottages, Rocklands Lodges, Barker Stakes Farm and The Old Manse Pickering all list pets allowed.
Is parking available?
Free car parking is listed at The Horseshoe Inn, Low Costa Mill, Craven Garth Cottages, The Fox and Hounds Country Inn, The Cayley Arms, The White Swan Inn, The Barn at Rigg End, 25 West End, The Barn at Noelles Cottages, High Farm Bed & Breakfast, The Old Manse Pickering, Rocklands Lodges, Rawcliffe House Farm and Barker Stakes Farm.
Which hotels are best for families?
Low Costa Mill has family rooms, a playground, high chairs and a cot. Barker Stakes Farm offers family rooms, a playground, table tennis and cots. Craven Garth Cottages and The Cayley Arms also list family rooms among their facilities.
Which hotel has the highest guest rating?
The Barn at Rigg End scores 5.0 out of 5 from 7 reviews. The Horseshoe Inn and Low Costa Mill each score 4.8, from 788 and 101 reviews respectively.
Do any of these hotels serve breakfast?
The White Swan Inn and High Farm Bed & Breakfast list breakfast. The White Swan Inn and The Fox and Hounds Country Inn also offer breakfast in room, and The Horseshoe Inn, The Fox and Hounds Country Inn and The White Swan Inn serve lunch.
Can I stay near the North Yorkshire Moors Railway?
The White Swan Inn on Market Place and The Old Manse Pickering on Middleton Road are both in Pickering, close to the station area. The Horseshoe Inn in Levisham is in a village with its own stop on the railway line.