Top 10 Hotels in Pickering (2026)
2 The Square, Grassington: Honest Verdict for Solo Young Travellers
Top 10 Hotels in Pickering: Discover our ranked list for 2026, from The Horseshoe Inn to Beansheaf Hotel, chosen by star rating and guest reviews.
Top 10 Hotels in Pickering: the list at a glance
Planning a stay in Pickering? Our list of the top 10 hotels in Pickering for 2026 highlights a range of properties, each with a strong star rating according to its own listing. From historic inns like The Black Bull Inn to countryside retreats such as Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest, these hotels offer a variety of settings for your visit.
We ranked each hotel by its star rating, then by guest rating. Properties with ratings from very few reviews were placed lower to ensure a fair comparison. This approach surfaces well-regarded stays, whether you prefer a traditional inn, a boutique hotel, or self-catering cottages.
The resulting list includes The Horseshoe Inn, The Old Cartway, The Black Bull Inn, Low Costa Mill, Craven Garth Cottages, The Fox and Hounds Country Inn, The Cayley Arms, Best Western Forest & Vale Hotel, Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest, and Beansheaf Hotel. Each has earned its place through strong star ratings and positive guest feedback.
1. The Horseshoe Inn; 2. The Old Cartway; 3. The Black Bull Inn; 4. Low Costa Mill; 5. Craven Garth Cottages; 6. The Fox and Hounds Country Inn; 7. The Cayley Arms; 8. Best Western Forest & Vale Hotel; 9. Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest; 10. Beansheaf Hotel.
1. The Horseshoe Inn
4-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.8/5 from 788 reviews | Bars, Free car parking, Parking, Garden.
The Horseshoe Inn is a 4-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.8 from 788 reviews. This hotel offers bars, free car parking, parking, a garden, a kitchen, a washing machine, a fireplace, a golf course, a laundry service, free wifi, and non-smoking rooms. With its high star rating and excellent guest feedback, it suits a range of guests, including those who appreciate leisure facilities and the convenience of on-site parking.
2. The Old Cartway
3-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.8/5 from 117 reviews | Free car parking, Parking, Pets allowed, Garden.
The Old Cartway is a 3-star hotel in Pickering. It holds a guest rating of 4.8 from 117 reviews. Amenities include free car parking, parking, pets allowed, a garden, a kitchen, a washing machine, a fireplace, and non-smoking rooms. Its peaceful setting and thoughtful facilities make it a good choice for guests who want a comfortable stay with the option to bring along their pets.
3. The Black Bull Inn
3-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.6/5 from 1,222 reviews | Restaurant(s), Free car parking, Free Wifi.
The Black Bull Inn is a 3-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.6 from 1,222 reviews. The hotel features a restaurant, free car parking, and free wifi. With its dining option and parking, it is well-suited to guests looking for a straightforward stay with easy access to meals and connectivity.
4. Low Costa Mill
4-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.8/5 from 101 reviews | Swimming pool, Indoor pool, Free car parking, Parking.
Low Costa Mill is a 4-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.8 from 101 reviews. Amenities include a swimming pool, an indoor pool, free car parking, parking, family rooms, a playground, pets allowed, a garden, a kitchen, a washing machine, a fireplace, and a laundry service. The combination of family-friendly facilities and high guest ratings makes it ideal for families and guests seeking recreational activities on site.
5. Craven Garth Cottages
4-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.8/5 from 100 reviews | Free car parking, Parking, Family rooms, Pets allowed.
Craven Garth Cottages is a 4-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.8 from 100 reviews. Amenities include free car parking, parking, family rooms, pets allowed, a garden, a kitchen, a kitchenette, a washing machine, a fireplace, a golf course, a laundry service, and free wifi. With spacious accommodation and numerous conveniences, it suits families, pet owners, and guests who enjoy self-catering with the option of golf nearby.
6. The Fox and Hounds Country Inn
4-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.6/5 from 443 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Room Service, Free car parking.
The Fox and Hounds Country Inn is a 4-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.6 from 443 reviews. Amenities include a restaurant, bars, room service, free car parking, parking, a garden, a terrace, a golf course, wheelchair accessibility, a laundry service, free wifi, and air conditioning. The range of facilities and its high rating make it suitable for guests who value comfort, dining, and accessibility.
7. The Cayley Arms
4-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.6/5 from 438 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Free car parking, Parking.
The Cayley Arms is a 4-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.6 from 438 reviews. Amenities include a restaurant, bars, free car parking, parking, a garden, a golf course, a laundry service, free wifi, and non-smoking rooms. With its dining options and well-regarded service, it appeals to guests looking for a comfortable stay with easy access to leisure activities.
8. Best Western Forest & Vale Hotel
3-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.6/5 from 380 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast, Room Service.
Best Western Forest & Vale Hotel is a 3-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.6 from 380 reviews. Amenities include a restaurant, bars, breakfast, room service, free car parking, parking, a garden, a terrace, a laundry service, free wifi, and non-smoking rooms. The combination of dining, outdoor space, and convenient services makes it a good fit for guests seeking a relaxing stay.
9. Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest
3-star hotel | Pickering | guest rating 4.8/5 from 65 reviews | Swimming pool, Jacuzzi, Free car parking, Parking.
Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest is a 3-star hotel in Pickering. It has a guest rating of 4.8 from 65 reviews. Amenities include a swimming pool, a Jacuzzi, free car parking, parking, family rooms, pets allowed, a beach nearby, a garden, a terrace, a kitchen, a washing machine, and a fireplace. With its family-friendly features and proximity to the beach, it is ideal for families and guests who enjoy outdoor activities.
10. Beansheaf Hotel
2-star hotel | Malton, Pickering | guest rating 4.5/5 from 188 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Free Wifi, Non smoking rooms.
Beansheaf Hotel is a 2-star hotel in Malton. It has a guest rating of 4.5 from 188 reviews. Amenities include a restaurant, bars, free wifi, and non-smoking rooms. Its dining and bar facilities, along with its solid guest rating, make it a practical choice for travellers looking for a simple and comfortable stay.
How we picked these hotels
How we picked: We identified hotels in Pickering with strong star ratings from their own listings. Each property was then ranked first by star rating, then by guest rating. To maintain fairness, hotels with ratings from very few reviews were ranked lower, as a smaller sample size can be less reliable. This method highlights consistently well-rated hotels across a range of styles and locations. No other factors influenced the ranking.
Tips for hotels stays in Pickering
Book early, especially during peak seasons, as hotels in Pickering can fill up quickly.
Check whether your hotel offers parking, as some properties in town may have limited spaces.
If you prefer a quieter stay, consider hotels just outside the town centre.
Look for hotels with on-site dining or a pub, which can be convenient after a day of exploring.
Confirm check-in times and any specific policies directly with the hotel before you travel.
Best areas in Pickering for hotels
When looking for hotels in the Pickering area, consider the nearby towns and villages that also offer accommodation. Malton has the most qualifying hotels, with nine, making it a strong choice if you want a wide selection. Helmsley follows with five qualifying hotels, ideal for those seeking a smaller market town atmosphere. Whitby, with two qualifying hotels, is perfect if you want a coastal stay. Each area provides a different experience: Malton for variety, Helmsley for charm, and Whitby for seaside views. All are within reach of Pickering, so you can enjoy the town while staying in one of these locations.
Before you book
The questions people ask about Grassington, answered with this month’s numbers.
Our top 10 hotels in Pickering for 2026 are The Horseshoe Inn, The Old Cartway, The Black Bull Inn, Low Costa Mill, Craven Garth Cottages, The Fox and Hounds Country Inn, The Cayley Arms, Best Western Forest & Vale Hotel, Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest, and Beansheaf Hotel.
We selected hotels with strong star ratings from their own listings, then ranked them by star rating and guest rating. Hotels with ratings from very few reviews were ranked lower to ensure a fair and reliable list.
All hotels on our list have strong star ratings according to their own listings. The exact ratings vary, but each property met our criteria for inclusion. The ranking order reflects both star rating and guest rating.
Yes, our list includes properties like Low Costa Mill, Craven Garth Cottages, and Middlehead Cottages at Cropton Forest, which offer cottage-style or self-catering accommodation alongside traditional hotel stays.
Malton has nine qualifying hotels, Helmsley has five, and Whitby has two. These areas provide additional options if you wish to stay near Pickering but prefer a different town or coastal setting.
Some hotels may have fewer reviews, and those were ranked lower in our list to avoid skewing the results. We prioritized properties with a more established guest rating for a fair comparison.
Yes, The Black Bull Inn, The Fox and Hounds Country Inn, and The Cayley Arms are examples of historic inns on our list, offering traditional hospitality alongside other hotel types.
